Wednesday, February 8, 2017

5. Innovation, Gender, and Definitions of Making

It was interesting to hear our class debate the merits of Dougherty’s comments on gender and play during last week’s discussion. Depending on your perspective, Dougherty was either redeemed or denied credibility on his assertion that gender expectations should not impede a child’s desire to play with the toys that spark their imaginations best. Can Dougherty authoritatively speak on the issue of gender and making, particularly when the movement he has cultivated is so male-dominated and male-oriented? This discussion point harkened back to earlier discussions we have had about women feeling unwelcome in makerspaces based on the atmosphere, the tools available, or even the facilities (i.e. bathrooms) that are accessible to them. Ultimately, the ability of the maker movement to be more inclusive towards women depends on the conceptions and definitions it allows about itself. Do activities that fall under categories like crafting, traditionally done by women, constitute making?

The Lilypad Arduino video by Becky Stern answers that question with a resounding, “YES!!” Stern gives a methodical overview of how to embroider LED lights powered by an Arduino onto a piece of fabric. Her step-by-step overview of how to sew on the Arduino and code the light pattern (as the Arduino is coded to direct the electricity it receives from an embroidered battery pack) illustrates how embedded systems can be used to enhance traditionally feminine pursuits like sewing, embroidery, or dressmaking. Including the skills associated with these pursuits and delivering an innovative twist on them proves the argument that these skills belong under the maker umbrella. Furthermore, the hybridity of embroidery with Arduino creates an access point that might otherwise be left abandoned. Ensuring access to maker technology is critical, according to Massimo Banzi, the founder of Arduino, who makes the case that “if you’re not able to participate in the world of creation, in the digital space, you’re left out, somebody else is going to design your world.”[1] For women and other people who might not fit the masculine paradigm of what a maker “is” or considered “to be”, it is of high importance to emphasize that the skills that Becky Sterm demonstrates in her video are applicable to maker technologies like the Arduino. This emphasis has the potential to break those paradigms, or what Banzi refers to as “the answer to a question” [2] that no one is debating. One of the important themes that we should take away this week is how innovation not only engenders revolutionary products but also revolutionary mentalities that displace old ones.

--
[1] Banzi, Massimo. "Massimo Banzi: Building Arduino." Computer. Interview by Charles Severance. January 2014. 
[2] Banzi, "Massimo Banzi: Building Arduino," 2014. 

          

Wednesday, February 1, 2017

SPECIAL POST: Socially Conscious Crafting and Making with Joe Sacco



About two weeks ago, I attended the Stamps Lecture at the Michigan Theater, where I managed to find a seat within a crowded auditorium. The speaker was comic writer and illustrator Joe Sacco, who is famous for creating incisive graphic novels representing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the Bosnian war. I came in knowing nothing about the author, as I have read very few graphic novels and have never had any particular obsession with comics (digital or otherwise). However, I left with a greater sense of the process of crafting and making, and how the overall products of these processes carry social responsibility.

A few of the takeaways from the talk that I found captivating include the idea that emotions like anger are useful to draw from while crafting. Mr. Sacco spoke of anger as a productive emotion, arguing that “there are plenty of things to be angry about. You should be angry. But that anger needs to go somewhere. All of my work comes from anger.” These comments made me reflect on the nature of the creative process and how powerful emotion can often profoundly influence a work one is making. But are powerful emotions like these allowed in a makerspace? I would hazard a guess that anger would be considered disruptive in a collective maker setting rather than conducive to creativity. Does this mean that some creative acts must be produced alone, in order to maximize inspiration? At what point do our efforts to enhance creativity in a space conflict with collective values and expectations?

Another idea that I felt contradicted the maker ethos/movement that we have been reading about is the idea that Mr. Sacco presented that one craft is inherently more intimate than another. Sacco was explaining that he saw his writings and illustrations as representations, and that it felt more personally invasive to draw someone than write about them. The act of recording a person’s appearance felt more intimate to him than recording a person’s words. This direct appraisal of these two maker activities and judging whether one is more intimate than the other also contrasted with the maker movement, which tries to proclaim that all maker activities are somehow equal and thus, produce the same feelings of satisfaction or pride. Yet, I think Sacco’s insights reveal the inherent differences between different activities under the maker umbrella and call into question the characterizations that have been made about what is considered a maker activity and what effect it produces.


Overall, I felt Sacco’s talk gave me a lot of thought as to what making looks like to an artist that is continuously engaging with his subjects in a real-life basis and has real implications. My analysis of the maker movement so far is that it has mostly focused on those who make for personal satisfaction or profit rather than engaging their making in a socially-conscious way. I personally wonder how individual emotions can fit into a collective space, where making and learning is at its greatest potential, and I wish Sacco could have touched upon the power of collective emotion in an artistic space rather than just individual emotion. Yet, I felt that his talk illuminated some key questions that I had not thought to ask before.

Joe Sacco (left) discussing the political implications of his work at the Stamps Lecture on January 19, 2017 at the Michigan Theater.

Monday, January 30, 2017

4. Owls & Arduinos: The Debate Between Product Versus Process in the Maker Movement

As we all gathered around a table to work on our in-class LED circuit projects, I kept thinking about the parallels and dissimilarities between our ongoing making and “the owl story” that Kristin brought up earlier in class. I did feel there was  some traits of this activity analogous to the owls, especially the show-and-tell at the end of class that highlighted those who successfully created a circuit in a creative way, leaving the unsuccessful to draw unflattering comparisons with their own work. Yet, I also felt the diverse and creative imaginations of our group combined with the open-ended nature of the task led to very individualized projects that would lead the maker to derive whatever satisfaction or disappointment they got out of the process. In addition, we shared our materials as a group, which in turn became an exchange of ideas as to how we could help each other make a switch for our own circuits. The disappointment that the girl felt after making her owl might have to do with the tension that Nicco brought up of product versus process or means versus ends. Ultimately, I think our class activity focused more on the process than the product itself, which I believe created an entirely different atmosphere that, although not entirely eliminating the disappointments and self-doubting comparisons inherent in making, contributes to a collective confidence and cooperation in the making experience.

I think these examples lend well to discussion of this week’s readings, which overwhelmingly emphasized the making of expensive technology and tools accessible to those who might not have the income or the education to utilize them. Explanations of the Arduino, for instance, cast it as a cheap microcontroller that levels the playing field, saying that “thanks to Arduino’s simplicity and ease-of-use, embedded systems [1] and programming now have a much lower barrier of entry than before.” [2] Designing opportunities for people to practice important skills like programming and learn about the integral use of embedded systems allows for a demystifying and democratization of knowledge around how technology operates in our society. The New York Times article detailing the transformations of libraries into “hands-on creative hubs” and the embrace of a “library of things” also demonstrates how the circulation of expensive tools can have an impact on technical learning. [3]

These open-access snapshots provide valuable insight into how people are responding to the maker movement, with an emphasis on making “making” as an accessible activity for all. Yet, the owl story throws a wrench into this movement’s ethos: what happens if making becomes all about the end result instead of the sharing experience? In his description of the “maker mindset,” Dougherty acknowledges that the maker community sees sharing as “the default setting” [4], which would lead one to believe that the maker movement is about collaboration and idea exchange for the greater good. Yet, Dougherty insists that “it would be wrong to think of openness as a requirement” and that people share for expressly the personal benefits of sharing. [5] Ultimately, this inability to separate the individualistic “product” approach from the collective “process” approach prevents a coherent message to resound from the maker movement. The owl story reveals just that.  

--
[1] According to Wikipedia, an embedded system is a “computer system with a dedicated function within a larger mechanical or electrical system” such as a traffic light or a digital watch!
[2] Robinson, Scott. “What Is Arduino?” September 14, 2015. http://stackabuse.com/what-is-arduino/.
[3] Brown, Patricia Leigh. “These Public Libraries Are for Snowshoes and Ukuleles.”  (The New York Times), September 15, 2015. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/us/these-public-libraries-are-for-snowshoes-and-ukuleles.html.
[4] Dougherty, Dale (with Ariane Conrad). Free to Make: How the Maker Movement is Changing Our Schools, Our Jobs, and Our Minds. (Berkeley, CA: North Atlantic Books, 2016), p. 159.
 [5]  Dougherty, Free to Make, pp. 159-160.